edited to add: This post has the sole intent of talking about a real issue that is happening in the online world of writing. I intentionally am not naming any names, listing any sites, or giving other specifics because I want to only talk about this issue of plagiarism. Please also note that I have received an email apology and that the post was taken down. ~Rachel
Yesterday, I found out that some of my writing, my Dear Sweet Mom Who Feels Like She is Failing post, was plagiarized.
I’m talking about taking my words word for word for word and then taking my pictures of my sink and my hair in a messy bun and my Samuel and then using them in a post without any reference to me. I’m talking about cutting out the end of my post that lists a link to my other dear mom letters and my subscribe box because that would give away that it was my work and not the person who pretended it was theirs. I’m talking about listing, under author, someone else’s name.
That? That is stealing.
I remember the morning I wrote that letter in August. It was sunny and beautiful and I was trying to write a sweet reply back to a lovely reader but she didn’t leave an email so I instead wrote an entire post. I remember sitting on my patio furniture with the sun rising and my cup of coffee with Italian Sweet Cream creamer in it while the words about not failing and you matter and do one thing came from my head and found their way on screen. I remember. I wrote those words.
And someone, another site, who I will not list, completely took it and never once within the post gave any little bit of credit back to me.
So last night as I scrubbed peanut butter that was ground into my family room floor by my little Samuel while I was upstairs getting in contact with an attorney about getting my work removed I thought about ignoring it. I really did. But the more I scrubbed at the peanut butter that shouldn’t have been there if I hadn’t had to deal with someone who decided to take my words and claim them as their own the more I realized that I really couldn’t be silent.
It may look like just words on a screen. I know. But, let me tell you – there is a great deal of work, thought, and well, work again that goes into each and every post. I stay up late. I rise early. And I work. And my work, my writing, was taken.
I know I’m not the only one this has happened to in the online blogging world {read this post by Kelby Carr}. I know because of the amazing outpouring of support that rallied around me with regards to this letter being found elsewhere. I also know that today instead of writing my normal stuff — which is what I should be writing about instead of plagiarism — I needed to speak up and be another voice for bloggers and writers and journalists.
Tucked way down on the bottom of my site I’ve had to embed a copyright code that protects myself. I’d love to just be able to write and share my heart and not really worry about this stuff. In fact, my hope is that my vulnerability blesses others and that by me being real it gives a chance for others to be real. And I really want mothers to know that they are not alone and that they matter. But, now, today, I am writing about something that never should have happened.
So I’m asking you to share this message. I’m asking you to support not only me in this fight, but all the other website owners and writers and photographers that are having to deal with outright stealing.
It must stop.
No one wins. My night was spent being distracted instead of intentional. The individual who stole my words will now have to deal with the repercussions of taking someone else’s property – because, you know, that is what it truly is – property. And you all are instead of getting to read tips on intentional parenting or why I love my kids more than spilled milk or those dear mom letters are getting to read these fighting for what is right words of mine.
I could go on and on and on listing rules and laws regarding plagiarism and how this is a direct form of copyright infringement and that this is against the law, but I’m not going to. They’re there.
Instead? I thank all of you for supporting me. For sharing links, clicking like, sending emails. And for all of you have emailed and asked if you could republish my works in magazines, newspapers, and on other websites. I appreciate you asking and us working together to build community. This is not about clicking like, sharing, and all of that. In fact, as website owners we greatly appreciate all of that and I want you to know that is awesome. Please keep sharing. 🙂
Tomorrow? I will get back to my normal voice and will write words about motherhood and what a gift it truly is to walk and that sometimes your backyard looks like an ad for Little Tikes. Today? Today was my day to stand up for what is right and to speak up for writers and website owners and photographers everywhere.
That is it.
~Rachel
47 comments
go for you! will definitely be spreading the word.
I am so sorry that you are going through this! I always enjoying reading your heart on your site…and I know that it is your heart. I will be praying for you as you go through this fight. God has given us all unique gifts and yours has ministered to me so often. I know I don’t comment very often…but I wanted you to know that you are in my prayers and I will be sharing this article and supporting you as you stand up for yourself and all of us who share our hearts on our blogs and websites hoping to encourage others but not expecting to have our words stolen. God bless you sister!
Blessings!
Mary Joy
I will retweet and share this. I guess, if it’s any consolation, someone thought it was great enough to steal. And you seem like the kind of nice enough person not to be “litigious,” which you totally could if you wanted to.
Rachel, I am so sorry that you had to be distressed and distracted by this. The post was such a heartfelt and honest outpouring of feelings. I’m sure that you felt very hurt. I will repost. It could happen to any of us. Thank you for sharing your thoughts.
This is a heart-breaking, devastating issue. I shall be keep you in my prayers…
xxAcacia
PS I’m spreading the word! I posted the link of this post on twitter. 🙂
It is sad when people take from others. It has eternal impacts – especially when encouraging others from Christ – in the end, it’s not just taking from a person, it is stealing from God – that is one of the ten commandments. This is what happens when you take the Word of God out of everything, yes, sin has been around since the fall in the garden…but, sitting back and watching more and more people work for their own glory….this is what happens. It’s sad. I’ll pray for you and for the person (or people) who did this. In the end, God will judge, but for me….I’ll continue to pray and love others….that will cover all sin and conquer the hurt of the heart. Many blessings to you and so sorry for what you have having to endure through this.
Happened to me and by a “good” friend… Thanks for taking a stand!!
I am sorry you are dealing with this. I saw last night which letter had been plagiarized. I just wanted to take a minute and share how you encouraged me when I read that letter (on your blog!!!) the first time. My sister had shared the link. I sat at my computer with tears streaming down my face at the timing the Lord had used your words to my heart. So, in the midst of your chaos today, thanks for your writing! (And, may all the peanut butter stay where it should today!!) Blessings to you!
Hi…I just read this and immedietly posted it on my FB page. I hope you can enjoy your day and beautiful children and as Dory says in Finding Nemo…”Just keep on swimmin’, just keep on swimmin'”….Thnanks for your lovely thoughts and words!
{{HUGS}} Classy lady, I said it yesterday and I will say it again today… I hope you sue their pants off… with righteous indignance, of course.
They say copying is the highest form of flattery, however in this instance copying is downright illegal, an infringement of Intellectual copyright! I’m happy you posted your thoughts here, Rachel and know we are all standing in the gap for you.
So too, we should continue to link arms and be secure in the knowledge that comes from the sister-hood of like-minded bloggers. And, that is continuing to help in promotion of each other and in instances such as these watching each other’s back.
I pray blessings and will watch as you still choose “Joy.”
I am so sorry this has happened to you. Praying for a simple resolution and that it does NOT happen to you again! Thank you for speaking out. I am sharing this all over the place!
You and your sweet family are always in my daily prayers. So sorry that happened to you! Glad the issue has been resolved. God bless you!
I just don’t know how people like this can live with themselves. I was very moved by that post as I bet you were when you wrote it. I really felt like I was sitting beside you, with you telling me about your day. How dare someone else think they could do the same? Their time will come. I will share this post on FB, as I do with most of them.
Anne @ Domesblissity (Australia)
SO sorry that this happened to you, Rachel. Way to stand up for all of us! Great article. I will be sharing this one…AND GIVING CREDIT! Thanks for your words of truth.
Rachel, if you google the first line of your “Dear Mom” post, you’ll see it’s on LOTS of other blogs. Sometimes in its entirety.
What a shame some people think wholesale lifting of someone else’s post is blogging!
Hi Rachel, I am very sad to hear about this and hope it is resolved soon. However, my first thought was, have you contacted the other party and asked her to pull it down? The Word tells us to go to someone one-on-one when they sin against us, and also encourages us to avoid suing others (especially believers) if at all possible and to strive for peaceful reconciliation. Maybe, just maybe, she is ignorant to the law, and especially to the offense to you. This might be a great opportunity to shine…
As you said ‘intellectual property’ is property, the same as any other item that you own. Stealing thoughts is the same as if someone came in your home and stole a TV or computer. As a working preacher, I use many sources for serman inspiration, but always credit the author. I would never publish a sermon without the proper authorization from the original author to do so.
I just found your blog yesterday from another bloggers link on Twitter. I loved it and shared the link on Facebook because I too have been there. I thought your message was spot on and so many people could benefit from hearing those kind words. It is unfortunate that somebody would take such a great positive post and turn it into such an awful experience. Good luck and please keep blogging. 🙂
I have only found your site recently but I am a huge fan already. I am so sorry that happened! I do appreciate what you shared though and will share it too!
Bless you, dear friend, for handling this HIS way. God will continue to bless and honor you for remaining kind throughout this ordeal. I am sorry you had to go through this. I am grateful for you and your love for us all. Keep smiling and loving that beautiful family of yours as you continue to seek His joy in all things! Love you sister 🙂
I’m so sorry this happened to you 🙁 I will share this post with all my blogging groups, to help spread the word!
honestly, this is outrageous. not your post, i mean, but that someone actually had the gall to steal your work, word for word. your pictures of your family and you. i’m with you all the way in this fight, and will definitely be spreading the word. xo
This comment has been removed by the author.
Take a risk, let it go. Like Paul said in Philippians so what if they are a bunch of hypocritical sinners, the Gospel is being shared because of them. Dont squeeze your possessions so tightly, your words so close that they stay with you. Throw them out there with purpose, praying they dont return void. Give freely and let the Lord sort out the drama. Charity doesnt keep record. Be flattered someone wanted to imitate you. Yes of course they were wrong, but they are also human. You sin too right? Forgive. Dont post their sin on your blog, you dont want your sin posted right? Love this person, take them under your wing, counsel them, spur them on to write their own things. Encourage. Do you want God to hold you accountable for every time you faked it?
Thank you. I agree that stealing is wrong, even of words… But what you said strikes home with me. I have been working hard to “love with my hands held open” and
Many times this means letting go of things that I hold on to…both possessions and feelings.
So sorry that you are having to go through this. You always speak from your heart and are so real and the love you have for your family is so evident. I know (some) how much effort,time, thought, prayer and reflection it takes to pour your heart onto paper/screen like you do. It’s your time , your energy, your family,your experiences, lessons learned, your heart. You don’t get more exposed or vulnerable than that. You have a lot invested in your work! We are so thankful you take the time to share your insight and wisdom with us and encourage us. Your blog helps encourage me to be better, to do better, to “live intentionally” and therefore helps strengthen me, my kids, my family…you are making a big impact in others lives! I’m sure you feel a wide range of emotions over this violation. I am sorry , this post (all of them) are well written, thought out and from the heart. Thank you and please know that many prayers are being sent your way. There are many things we can learn from each of your posts and you write with encouragement always…and today you encourage us to do what needs to be done, to take time to stand up for what is right, even when it’s hard and even when we are busy. You are teaching your family a valuable lesson about respecting others, their property and respecting ourselves and our work and taking positive action to make positive changes when and where necessary. Thank you and God Bless!
Rachel, so sorry this happened to you. Thank you so much for sharing this so the rest of us can make sure it doesn’t happen to us, either! I hope it all works out okay!
I love your honest, hard response to this, and hold you in my heart today. Thanks for raising the banner, Rachel. More people need to see this and know the truth about plagiarism–that it’s theft, plain and simple.
Praying for a quick resolution.
I’m so sorry that you have to go through this. Though I’m not a blogger and I’m not a young mom either…..I’m a grandma who loves reading the dedication of you moms and how you are teaching your children about the Lord. About the easier days and the often very hard days. I so appreciate your transparency. Though I’ve never been a blogger, I have been a speaker in the past before I had some health issues that have set me in a different place learning different lessons for a season. But I do remember that when I wrote something that I was going to speak on, those words, each turn of phrase, each expression was prayerfully put on paper to present. As you say, it is fine for people to ask to share, but to just steal is wrong, wrong, wrong. I will be praying for you, dear girl. You have a real gift and God is using you….don’t let the evil one discourage you. Be lifted up by God’s grace today. He loves you and He loves how honest you are about YOUR life. Much love in him……Jane
Really?? Wow. I will share the post, and pray this works out and the person never steals again!
For those who mentioned Rachel should just let this go, no she shouldn’t. This is breaking the law. As far as I know, she did ask them to take it down. They did. However, looking closely at other articles on the same site, it seems that others were also plagiarized. So, to me, it looks like they did know what they were doing and it should be addressed. I think Rachel handled this very professionally. I know she handled it a lot better than what I would have. In fact, they would have heard from my lawyer first. Well done, Rachel!!
Since when is it not godly to defend what is rightfully your’s? I’m sorry but God loves with a jealous love and protects His children. If a stranger came into your home and stole your grandmother’s fine china, would you let it go or fight to get it back? Fight to keep the thief from stealing other priceless treasures from other families? Would you try to talk it out face to face or seek help?
Rachel, THANK YOU for putting this out there and raising awareness. My prayer is that someone will read these words, realize their error, and change their ways.
* off topic- I love Italian sweet cream creamer!* Back on and more serious- recently a friend of mine, who is a garden blogger and had written many articles for yahoo had this happen to him. It was a ” friend” of his. She took whole posts and articles and erased his name and put her own. never gave him credit for anything. he hasn’t posted anything since. so sad. sorry this happened to you.
On the day I read that post, I had been reduced to tears by my ADHD/dyslexic daughter and 12-going-on-30 son. I had actually just said to my husband that I didn’t feel adequate for this, I couldn’t do it, we needed to look at private school.
I actually read that blot post aloud to my kids. We had a cry together and cuddled, and got back to work.
Your post changed my perspective, my home school, and my life. I love you for that.
Accept that some people are awful. Some people see something good and instead of recognizing greatness, want it for themselves.
I pinned that post to the Mind Of A Homeschool Mom group board on pinterest. It has been repinned countless times, with attribution. You’ve changed many hearts. Don’t let one act of selfishness cloud that.
This happened to a friend of mine and caused a long, ugly series of events (she knew the person). I fully agree that your content is YOURS. As a fellow writer, I know the time it takes. It is not “just” words and photos–it is your work and your property. If someone walked into a store and shoplifted, we wouldn’t just let them walk away. Your post is lovely and gracious,and I pray this can be dealt with quickly and be a lesson to others who would pilfer content that is not theirs. I am adding the copyscape to my own site. Blessings!
total support from this appreciative mama!
Copyright infringement rears it’s ugly head no matter if you are a Christian or not. It is a fact of law. Rachel followed the facts and that led her to the truth that people steal…
I think Rachel took the higher road discussing the facts and the issue and not attacking the plagiarist. Well done, Rachel.
Wow, this is horrible. You are right, no matter what you write, the words are yours and always come from your own heart and soul. Im so sorry that happened to you. Perhaps you should do a post teaching bloggers how to do an embeded copyright on our blogs? I can’t even figure out how you found out someone stole your words, but good for you! I know one time on one of my blogs, someone used one of my pictures of a scrapbooking layout on their blog so I commented that perhaps she could link to my site. I only found it because I was searching something in google and saw my name on something I didn’t recognize! Good luck with it all.
While I hate to be the bearer of bad news, there is another blog that posted it with NO credit give to you, Rachel.
http://ashleyj87.blogspot.com/2012/09/dear-mom-who-feels-like-she-is-failing.html
Two people have already commented but I think it could use a few more!
But hey, at least she didn’t steal your pictures. :/
I cna’t imagine how or why someone would steal your words, your heart, your mission…and think that it would then ‘work for them’. I never even thought about any of my posts being “taken”. Thank you for sharing, in hopes to stand for all us writers who own their words, their hearts, and their mission. 🙂
It is interesting that this is the second time this week I have read an article about plagarism among (supposedly) Christians. Thought you might enjoy reading Pastor James White’s thoughts on it, as he was recently plagarized himself.
So sorry that you’ve had to be violated in this way. It IS stealing, and probably even a more intimate theft, since the property was uniquely yours.
I read part of the article to my homeschooled middle-schooler, and we talked about WHY plagarism is the same as stealing. Know that your bad experience will be used for good in God’s Kingdom. Thank you for your honesty in sharing it, anger and all.
oops. Dr. White’s website/blog is:
http://www.churchandculture.org/Blog.asp?ID=3321
Oh, how hard for you! I can’t understand why people today have such a hard time respecting copyright. If someone has put a lot of time and their heart into a project, they deserve to get the credit for it. Glad that the site took it down, and hoping that it never happens to you (or anyone else) again!
Danielle, You response is AWESOME!
I love your writings. I find writing about the crazy times helps me to relax. Keep up the good work. 🙂
Thank you, Joy.